When it comes to big tech companies, the news of fines has become all too familiar. Price fixing, competition suppression, and data misuse seem to be recurring issues. However, what is more concerning is the fact that these fines often go unpaid for years. Recently, it was revealed that Meta (formerly known as Facebook) has not paid any of the two billion euros in fines that were issued since September of last year. TikTok also finds itself owing hundreds of millions, while Amazon is still in the process of appealing a 746 million euro fine from 2021. The list goes on, with Google disputing EU fines worth over eight billion euros and Apple fighting against a French antitrust fine of 1.1 billion euros and an order to pay 13 billion euros in tax to Ireland. This problem of unpaid fines extends beyond the big four tech companies, affecting tech firms of all sizes. For instance, Australia recently confirmed that X (formerly Twitter) failed to pay a fine imposed for not outlining its plans to combat content depicting child sexual abuse. Critics argue that merely imposing fines does not deter these companies from engaging in improper behavior, and it may be time to consider more drastic action.
A Familiar Pattern of Challenge
Margarida Silva, a researcher at the Dutch NGO the Centre for Research on Multinationals, points out that tech firms have long reveled in their reputation for “disruption.” Their failure to pay fines aligns with their tendency to challenge any enforcement of rules against them. Even if companies ultimately lose their legal battles, the lengthy appeal process they initiate exhausts significant time and resources from the administrative bodies overseeing the cases. Silva notes a distinction between tech and finance sectors, highlighting the latter’s continued incentive to pay fines as a means of reassuring the public and investors. However, Romain Rard, a lawyer at Gide Loyrette Nouel in Paris, suggests it is reasonable for firms to appeal substantial penalties. According to Rard, companies cannot simply ignore fines, but rather challenge the decisions in the hope of achieving a favorable outcome. Notably, some tech companies have experienced success in this regard, as chip firms Intel and Qualcomm recently saw billion-dollar EU antitrust fines overturned or considerably reduced after appealing.
The European Approach
Europe’s system differs from jurisdictions like China or the United States, where fines are often announced as settlements and come at the end of protracted processes. In 2019, Facebook paid a record $5 billion fine to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in the aftermath of the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Similarly, e-commerce giant Alibaba promptly settled a record nearly $3 billion fine with Chinese regulators in 2021. Activists argue that such companies are simply too financially powerful for these penalties to have a substantial impact. Max Schrems, an Austrian lawyer and prominent advocate for data rights in Europe, asserts that uneven application of regulations exacerbates the situation. Schrems believes that the Irish Data Protection Commission grants tech companies excessive leeway in the appeals process and imposes fines that are far too small. In response, Ireland’s deputy data protection commissioner, Graham Doyle, defended the commission’s record and emphasized that fines are only one aspect of its enforcement efforts. Doyle highlighted corrective measures imposed on Instagram as a result of an investigation into its handling of children’s data. While a 405 million euro fine is currently under appeal, Doyle stressed that Instagram had already addressed the initial problem. Activists agree that fines alone are insufficient, and competition regulators must take more decisive action. They advocate for halting future takeovers and mergers in the sector, undoing past damages, and potentially even breaking up these tech giants. According to Silva, the situation with Meta would be entirely different if the company had not been allowed to acquire Instagram and WhatsApp. AFP has reached out to Meta for a response on these issues.
The issue of unpaid fines in the tech industry persists and demands attention. While fines play a role in penalizing bad behavior, they alone are not enough to curb the illegal practices of tech companies. The history of challenge and appeals delays the payment of fines, and due to the financial strength of these companies, the impact of the penalties is often mitigated. It is high time for competition regulators to step up and take more drastic measures, such as prohibiting future mergers and acquisitions, undoing past consolidations, and even considering the breakup of these tech giants. Merely imposing fines is not an effective deterrent, and more decisive action is necessary to ensure fair competition and protect consumers and smaller businesses from the monopolistic practices of tech giants.
Leave a Reply